Monday, November 29, 1999

High court rules out review of tough crime legislation

News posted by www.newsinfoline.com

Mumbai, May 10 -- The Bombay High Court dismissed a petition seeking an order to set up a Review Committee for screening cases registered under the Maharashtra Control of Organised Crime Act (MCOCA). "We cannot issue a direction to the state government to amend the law or to enact a law and provide for a Review Committee," said the division bench of Justice Ranjana Desai and Justice Mridula Bhatkar while dismissing the petition filed by alleged "Pandav Putra" gang member Vijay Vashirde. "It will be a welcome step," observed the judges saying, "The state government will not be at a disadvantage if a provision for a review committee is made." The judges noted that the existing constitution of a review committee as recommended by the Supreme Court in the Shaheen Welfare Association's case will help prevent the possible misuse of the MCOCA. Vashirde's counsel S.R. Chitnis said the provisions of the MCOCA were drastic and perhaps more stricter than the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act. He argued there were several cases of misuse of the MCOCA and, therefore, the provision of the Review Committee, as incorporated in the Prevention of Terrorists Act (POTA), should be incorporated in the MCOCA.Senior lawyer V. R. Dhond, who argued for the state, said the nature and extent of safeguards and protections which ought to be introduced in a statute is a matter of policy in which the court cannot interfere.

News posted by www.newsinfoline.com

Click here to read more news from www.newsinfoline.com
Please follow our blogs

newsinfolinephotogallery
prabugallery
newsinfolinephotogallery1

photogallery1

No comments:

Post a Comment